LYRICS- Shut up and listen I've got a story Hear what you're missin', let the story unfold The tale is scary and grim and gory Involving a mare who's impossibly old
A spooky voice in the forest finds you You wonder what on earth could that ever be? You turn around and she's right behind you Your vision's hazy, you're unable to see
Don't be afraid of the olden pony She don't wanna do any harm Don't be afraid of the olden pony Run along back to your farm
So now you're tripping on rocks and boulders But you're not sure why you were screaming with fright Are you afraid just because she's older ...or are you scared because it's dark out tonight? Huh?
(Chorus) You're so scared that you just fell off a cliff Don't be afraid You could just have saved your own life if you weren't so afraid