Rachel: There were nights when the wind was so cold That my body froze in bed If I just listened to it Right outside the window
There were days when the sun was so cruel That all the tears turned to dust And I just knew my eyes were Drying up forever (Sugar, Tina, and Quinn: Forever)
I finished crying in the instant that you left And I can't remember where or when or how And I banished every memory you and I had ever made
But when you touch me like this And you hold me like that I just have to admit That it's all coming back to me When I touch you like this And you hold me like that It's so hard to believe but It's all coming back to me
Rachel with Sugar, Quinn, and Tina: It's all coming back, it's all coming back to me now There were moments of gold And there were flashes of light There were things I'd never do again But then they'd always seemed right
Rachel: There were nights of endless pleasure It was more than any laws allow Baby Baby
If I kiss you like this And if you whisper like that It was lost long ago But it's all coming back to me If you want me like this And if you need me like that It was dead long ago (With Quinn, Tina, and Sugar: But it's all coming back to me) It's so hard to resist And it's all coming back to me I can barely recall But it's all coming back to me now But it's all coming back
But you were history with the slamming of the door And I made myself so strong again somehow And I never wasted any of my time on you since then
Rachel with Quinn, Tina, Blaine, Rory, Mike and Sugar harmonizing: But if I touch you like this And if you kiss me like that It was so long ago But it's all coming back to me If you touch me like this And if I kiss you like that It was gone with the wind But it's all coming back to me
Rachel with Sugar, Quinn, and Tina: (It's all coming back, it's all coming back to me now)
Rachel: There were moments of gold And there were flashes of light There were things we'd never do again But then they'd always seemed right There were nights of endless pleasure It was more than all your laws allow Baby, Baby, Baby
Rachel with Quinn, Tina, Blaine, Rory, Mike and Sugar: When you touch me like this And when you hold me like that It was gone with the wind But it's all coming back to me When you see me like this And when I see you like that Then we see what we want to see All coming back to me The flesh and the fantasies All coming back to me I can barely recall But it's all coming back to me now
If you forgive me all this If I forgive you all that We forgive and forget And it's all coming back to me now
Quinn, Tina, and Sugar: (It's all coming back to me now)