Tina: If God had a name, what would it be And would you call it to His face If you were faced with Him in all His glory What would you ask if you had just one question?
Finn with New Directions: And yeah, yeah, God is great Yeah, yeah, God is good Yeah, yeah
Finn and Rachel: Yeah, yeah, yeah
Finn and Rachel with New Directions: What if God was one of us Just a slob like one of us Just a stranger on the bus Tryin' to make His way home Tryin' to make His way home
Kurt (with Quinn): (If God had a face) What would it look like? And (Would you want to see?) If seeing meant that you would (Have to believe) In things like Heaven (And in Jesus, and the Saints) And (All the Prophets)
Finn with New Directions: Yeah, yeah, God is great Yeah, yeah, God is good Yeah, yeah
Finn, Mercedes, and Rachel: Yeah, yeah, yeah
Finn, Mercedes, Rachel, and New Directions: What if God was one of us
Finn and Rachel and New Directions (Mercedes): Just a slob like one of us Just a stranger on the bus Tryin' to make His way home (Home)
Tryin’ to make His way home Back up to Heaven all alone Nobody callin’ on the phone (Phone) ‘Cept for the Pope maybe in Rome
Finn with New Directions: And yeah, yeah, God is great Yeah, yeah
Finn and Rachel with New Directions: God is good Yeah, yeah
Finn, Mercedes, Rachel, and New Directions: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah (Mercedes: Yeah!)
Rachel with New Directions (with Finn): What if God was one of us (Mercedes: What if God was one of us!) (Rachel: Oh) Just a (slob like one of us) (Mercedes: Just a slob like one of us!) (Rachel: Oh) Just a (stranger on the bus) (Tryin' to make His way home) (Mercedes: Tryin' to make his way home!) Just (tryin’ to make his way home) (Mercedes: Tryin' to find his way home!)
Rachel with New Directions (Mercedes): Just like a holy rollin' stone (Like a holy rollin' stone)
Finn with New Directions (with Mercedes): Back up to (Heaven all alone)
Rachel and New Directions (Tina): Just tryin’ to make his way home (Way home, uuuh)
Tina (New Directions): Nobody callin’ on the phone (Yeah, yeah, God is great) ‘Cept for the Pope maybe in Rome (Yeah, yeah, God is good) (Yeah, yeah, yeah...)