Verse 1: Jordan If I ever had love she's the first/ and she still has my t-shirt/ and I hope that my smell tells her a tale of how bad she's made me hurt// yeah i really wanna call her/ but i'm afraid that the caller i.d./ would simply just cause her to avoid the conversation, so let me say this// "I really wanna make out with you on Venice Beach// head up to Malibu then rent a suite and stain the sheets"// yeah, these are things that we used to do/ don't want them 'cause I'm still used to you/ wanna go back to that day up in Santa Cruz/ or when we held hands walking down Ocean Avenue (If I could find you now)/ and yeah I'm still mad at you/ 'cause I should be the one still having you/ I had to do what I had to do/ and I just hope that you feel it to...
Chorus: Jason/Jordan But now it's done, you were my first love// and now the next girl's gonna have to put up// with you consuming my thoughts/ confusing my talk/ and thinking 'bout us 'cause it's never gonna stop// no it's never gonna stop
Verse 2: BC Yeah that's what I used to say/ the only girls i'll ever need are you and Grace/ when I couldn't imagine gettin through a day/ without *insert a line that's overused, cliche*/ dang, can't even explain or paint a pic better than us right before the canvas turned gray// it was great, no debate, you were placed in my life, it was fate but it started feeling safe and hey// I never been content for perfect/ hard to even settle when it's worth it/ love like Aaliyah, you were my one-in-a-million/ but how many girls in the world? 3 billion/ meaning there's 3 thou one-in-a-millions/ check the ratio, I'm chillin/ then you played me so, lesson from the radio/ single is the way to go, sing...
Chorus: Katie But now it's done, you were my first love// and now the next guy's gonna have to put up// with you consuming my thoughts/ confusing my talk/ and thinking 'bout us 'cause it's never gonna stop// no it's never gonna stop
Verse 3: Katie Well I resist the urge to call you up 'cause i know i can't go back// but i give in just like that, i wanna be right where you're at// so you can dry my eyes and hold me close// don't wanna spend another night alone// i'll be a stronger, woman in the morning// i'll make it through another day/ forget the things i wish i didn't say/ but i can't, no i can't, no i can't stop lovin you baby...
Chorus: Katie But now it's done, you were my first love// and now the next guy's gonna have to put up// with you consuming my thoughts/ confusing my talk/ and thinking 'bout us 'cause it's never gonna stop// no it's never gonna stop
Chorus: Jason/Jordan ...You were my first love// and now the next girl's gonna have to put up// with you consuming my thoughts/ confusing my talk/ and thinking 'bout us 'cause it's never gonna stop// no it's never gonna stop