The Diva returns to her hometown as who she used to be, Sara Smith. No one recognizes her, or believes she is who she says she is. Her family has moved, her friends don't know her. She feels more alone than ever before ("Haddonfield (15 Years Later)").
Back in Greenpoint, Jesse gets himself clean, watching from afar as Nina struggles to maintain her success without his songs. It becomes impossible, and at the VMAs, she tries to sing a version of her old song (“Good For You (Reprise)”) that fails miserably. Nina spirals downward. Eventually, she comes back to Jesse, meeting him back at their bridge, and she sings about how she wants to change back into who she used to be, if he'll be there with her ("Heart-Shaped Wreckage").
Jimmy: I'm not scared to tell the truth I've been to hell and back and I went with you Remind me what we were before When we said "You are mine and I am yours"
Karen: I don't know much but I know myself And I don't wanna love anybody else So let's break the spell and lift the curse Remember why we fell for each other, head first
Jimmy: Look at this heart-shaped wreckage What have we done? We have got scars from battles Nobody won
We can start over, better Both of us know If we just let the broken pieces Let the broken pieces go
Karen: I can't find you in the dark Will we get back to who we are? And I can't fix this on my own Our love is still the best thing I've ever known
Both: Look at this heart-shaped wreckage What have we done? We have got scars from battles Nobody won
We can start over, better Both of us know If we just let the broken pieces Let the broken pieces go
Jimmy: Let the broken pieces go
Both: Just hold on to each other tonight
Karen: Oh oh oh...
Both: Look at this heart-shaped wreckage What have we done? We have got scars from battles Nobody won
We can start over, better Both of us know If we just let the broken pieces Let the broken pieces