[Verse 1:] 2,3,4 [Both:] Woo-hoo, Woo-hoo, Woo-hoo, Woo-hoo. [AJ:] Well my heart knows me better than I know myself so I'm gonna let it do all the talkin. [Both:] Woo hoo. Woo hoo. [AJ:] I came across a place in the middle of nowhere with a big black horse and a cherry tree. [Both:] Woo hoo. Woo hoo. [Aly:] I fell in fear upon my back He said don't look back just keep on walkin. [Both:] Woo hoo. Woo hoo. [Aly:] When the big black horse said Hey lady, look this way. Said Will you marry me? [Both:] Woo hoo. Woo hoo.
[Chorus:] [AJ:] But I said [Both:] No, no, no, no no no. [AJ:] I said no, no, you're not the one for me. I said [Both:] No, no, no, no no no. [AJ:] Your not the one [Aly:] For me.
[Verse 2:] [AJ:] And my heart had a problem in the early two hours, so I stopped it dead for a beat or two. [Both:] Woo hoo. Woo hoo. [AJ:] But I cut some cord and I shouldn't have done that and now it won't forgive me after all these years! [Both:] Woo hoo. Woo hoo. [Aly:] So I sent it to a place in the middle of nowhere with a big black horse and a cherry tree. [Both:] Woo hoo. Woo hoo. [Aly:] Now it wont come back cause it's oh so happy and now I've got a hole for the world to see! [Both:] Woo hoo. Woo hoo.
[Chorus]
[Bridge:] [Aly:] It said no, no, no, no, no, no no no. It said no no no. You're not the one for me. [AJ:] No, no, no, no, no, no no no You're not the one for me. You're not the one, you're not the one. [AJ:] Well there was a big black horse. And a cherry tree. Can't quite get there cause my heart has forsaken me. [Aly:] Big black horse and a cherry tree. [AJ:] Ha!